
Burgundy
2005
with perfect, healthy grapes and ideal harvest
conditions is regarded by many as the greatest
vintage in the modern era of Burgundy, rivaling
the great 1959s and eclipsing all vintages thereafter.
It is considered by many top growers to be as
close to perfection as any young Burgundy vintage
for the last fifty years.
Bruce Sanderson, of The Wine Spectator, which
is coincidentally featuring 2005 and 2006 Burgundies
in their next issue, May 31st, writes, "The
top wines are stunning. Since my last tasting
report I have blind tasted 570 2005 red Burgundies.
It's the type of vintage that comes along once,
maybe twice, a generation.The wines have loads
of everything-ripe fruit, acidity, tannins, color,
and the ability to age for a long time. I rate
the vintage 98 points. Unfortunately, greatness
comes at a price. The 2005 reds are the most expensive
red Burgundies ever released. For certain trophy
bottles, it seems that people are willing to pay
almost anything. Prices for the 2005s, which they
call a 'Monumental Vintage', have skyrocketed
since release. "
Please note that our prices have not skyrocketed
as most of our wines were bought before the
dollar sunk below the horizon. We still have adequate
if not excessive stocks of most wines but do suggest
not waiting to buy your favorites. These ARE GREAT
WINES and they are great from the bottom up. One
need not buy a purported "trophy" wine
to enjoy 2005 red Burgundy. And one should not
shun the excellent, fairly priced, wines from
2002, 2003 as they are delicious and drinkable.
Allen Meadows, Burghound.com writes, "My
in bottle tastings of the 2005s has served to
reinforce my original belief that the vintage
is one of the greatest in the history of modern
Burgundy. The best 2005s are simply sublime Burgundies
that will be capable of being exceptionally long-lived.
Each level of the Burgundian hierarchy transcends
its usual quality category and ascends to the
one directly above. Which is to say regional wines
perform like Villages wines, Villages wines like
good if not absolute top 1er crus, good 1er crus
are like solid grands crus, and the best grand
crus are well, simply unbelievable. Over all,
the best wines are truly transcendental and should
provide for magical drinking experiences over
a period of several decades; the best wines will
easily see 50 years in fine shape. 2005 is quite
simply the best top to bottom vintage that I have
ever seen, period, full stop. It is a brilliant
vintage with virtually nothing to dislike. I can
also report that many domaines made the best wines
that I have ever seen from them. In short, mortgage
your house, sell your dog, hock your spouse, or
do whatever you have to do but don't miss the
best wines of the vintage or you will I believe
live to regret it. My advice is to buy up and
down the food chain and do NOT avoid purchasing
regional and villages level wines." Allen
Meadows - Burghound.com
Bruce Sanderson, in the Wine Spectator previously
wrote, "The 2005 vintage for red and white
Burgundy has everything you could want: ripe fruit,
fresh acidity, well integrated tannins and great
balance." France's prestigious Revue du Vin
de France wrote, "2005, a GREAT FUTURE FOR
BURGUNDY! Our tastings confirmed the greatness
of this vintage. Generous and dense fruit for
the reds, with beautiful substance and very elegant
tannins. Beautiful richness and structure is evident
in the whites. Our advice: Do not wait to reserve
these beautiful wines." "At the risk
of throwing another log on an already raging fire,
I'd have to say that 2005 is potentially the greatest
red Burgundy vintage I've tasted from the barrel,
and I've been sampling these wines in depth every
year since the 1987 vintage." Stephen Tanzer,
International Wine Cellar Issue 131 (April, 2007)